Update 2022: My views have changed since writing this blog in 2019 but I still believe the marriage and divorce of Israel are wonderful metaphors for our covenant with Yahweh. My views on the bride of Yahweh have changed and I will put this caution symbol ⚠️ along with a brief explanation besides points I no longer agree with.
A beautiful sermon was taught at my church this week (1/19/2019) and it was the same day I had studied the Torah portion B’Shalach. I had a few light bulbs going off but also some linger questions that needed answering. I’ve recently concluded that God is always speaking to us we just need to learn to listen better and connect the dots. Just the fact that the sermon was on Hosea made me raise an eyebrow since I had just been telling my wife about that book and how it had led me on a much different walk in my spiritual life several years back. The spiritual walk may sometimes appear as though you go in circles, but each circuit gives improved perspective as if you were walking a spiraling road up a tall peak. You view the same thing below but now you see farther and further than before. Scripture is like this as well, every time you reread a book you see it with new eyes through the wisdom you’ve gained.
The teacher stopped at chapter 3 at which point the rest of the book quickly loses its redemptive tone. It’s books like this that Richard Dawkins loves to use to paint Yahweh as a heartless, petty child; but the scales over this man’s eyes are very thick. Yeshua himself tells us there will be people like this who study the scriptures but miss the deeper meanings and come away with a hardened heart.
Here is why I speak to them in parables: they look without seeing and listen without hearing or understanding. Matthew 13:13
We are shown that Hosea’s relationship with his prostitute wife, Gomer, is an analogy for Yahweh’s covenant with Israel and her children (Yizre’el—G-d will sow, Lo-ruchamah—unpitied, Lo-Ammi—not my people) are the people of the nations of the world that come to faith in Yahweh. We also pick up early in the book that there is a redemptive plan for the bride and her children. Later it is mentioned that Hosea is to remarry/take back Gomer (which is interesting for those of you familiar with Torah and what it says about divorce which we’ll look at later).
I’ve come to see the Covenants Yahweh has made with his people as a marriage relationship: ⚠️The book of Hosea is using the marriage of the prophet to an unfaithful wife as an example of unfaithful Israel but their covenant with Yahweh is not a marriage covenant.
*The Abrahamic Covenant was about faith: The wedding ceremony of Yah and Israel ⚠️ or simply entering into a contract
*The Mosaic Covenant about obedience: The marriage vows between both parties that would keep the bond strong ⚠️ rules of the contract
*The New Covenant about Grace: Israel divorced herself by not keeping the marriage vows and the relationship had to be renewed. Redeeming the bride is a process that involved Yeshua’s death and resurrection as a new bride-groom and his second coming. Just as in Jewish culture a man would go away for a year to build a home for his bride before bringing her there. ⚠️ broken rules resulting in the contract being void, resulting in the need for a new contract. This “divorce” is more of a land contract. The promised land was taken but a better promised land, New Jerusalem, will come.
One thing to note is that none of these Covenants replace the other, they’re all part of the same marriage relationship. ⚠️ the land contract is renewed.
In Hosea there are a few verses that make me wonder about what I’ve always been taught. That the church has replaced Israel and we are a second wife with a new covenant, but it seems clear based solely on Hosea that Yahweh plans to take Israel back.
2:19 and I will betroth you unto me forever.
Betroth—but they were already married, how can Yahweh take adulterous Israel as wife again? The context here is the end times when there will finally be no more war. The question that came to my mind was: is Israel still living in a divorced state?
Chapters one through three seem to detail the redemptive plan that is still being carried out. Most would counter and say the redemption ended at the crucifixion of the true Messiah, but I would argue it is not finished till we are called into the promised land to abide under the reign of Yeshua Ben David at His second coming. Let’s see if Hosea supports this idea, that although we have been called to be with Yeshua, we are not his full bride yet. This, of course, tags along with the idea that Israel is the only bride and the new covenant would best be described as a renewed covenant. The church then simply being a part of Israel, Yahweh’s chosen people, Ammi “My people”. ⚠️ again we need to be careful about taking the bride analogy literally, YHWH is using a concept we can understand to help us grasp His dealings with unfaithful Israel.
Hosea 3
1 ADONAI said to me, “Go once more, and show love to [this] wife [of yours] who has been loved by her boyfriend, to this adulteress – just as ADONAI loves the people of Isra’el, even though they turn to other gods and love the raisin cakes [offered to them].”
2 So I bought her back for myself with fifteen pieces of silver and eight bushels of barley.
3 Then I told her, “You are to remain in seclusion for a long time and be mine. You are not to be a prostitute, and you are not to be with any other man; and I won’t come in to have sex with you either.”
4 For the people of Isra’el are going to be in seclusion for a long time without a king, prince, sacrifice, standing-stone, ritual vest or household gods.
5 Afterwards, the people of Isra’el will repent and seek ADONAI their God and David their king; they will come trembling to ADONAI and his goodness in the acharit-hayamim. (Latter Days/time of the end)
Let’s skip to verse 4 for now. Here’s just my initial interpretation based on history:
- King=Yahweh, Prince=Messiah/Yeshua/G-d’s son.
- Sacrifice, standing-stone, ritual vest or household gods=no true Temple or Tabernacle, no sacrifices, no priests but also no other gods/elohim will join themselves to this people.
Your reactions should be mixed at this breakdown. Is it not a good thing that sacrifices have been done away with? Why is this painted as a negative thing? Perhaps we’ve been taught to think about this the wrong way. The tabernacle/temple was designed by Yahweh to allow Israel to come to the place where His spirit dwelled. The Sacrifices cleansed the land and kept our impurities from driving away that presence. These things are a blessing and to be scattered amongst the nations without a Temple limits our ability to interact with the Almighty. A friend of mine has written a short book on the Heavenly Temple and how it relates to the earthly Temple. https://www.facebook.com/DanielVadenDC/
The Deuteros Man is a detailed look at how the earthly rites that maintained our relationship with Yahweh are continued in a parallel way in heaven with Yeshua acting as our High-Priest. But overall, the point here is the Temple and associated feasts and sacrifices were to be a blessing to His people. Also, note that the Torah/God’s law has not been removed from Israel according to Hosea. We still have the ability to follow God’s commandments to the best of our ability to receive as much blessing as we can. In fact, Yahweh calls for us to seek His knowledge.
Hosea 4:6 My people are destroyed for want of knowledge. Because you rejected knowledge, I will also reject you as cohen (priest) for me. Because you forgot the Torah of your God, I will also forget your children.
I also underlined verse 3 above: “You are to remain in seclusion for a long time and be mine. You are not to be a prostitute, and you are not to be with any other man; and I won’t come in to have sex with you either.”
The marriage relationship is not completed here, it is something that needs repair. The parable of the 10 virgins comes to mind and I do not think its coincidence that there are 10 lost tribes of the Norther Kingdom. Yeshua was speaking of His second coming as the bridegroom. It’s clear all ten knew they were waiting on their husband (were aware of scripture and prophecy) but only five had oil (true faith). Paul speaks of a mystery and I think the scales were removed from his eyes for a very specific reason: he knew Torah like no other. Yeshua already had passionate disciples but he needed someone well educated in the words of the prophets (prophets like Hosea). He quotes from them many, many times and seeks to answer this mystery: how can an adulterous woman be taken back by her husband because, by God’s own law/Torah, that would be a sin and, worse, a contradiction for people like Richard Dawkins to scoff at—but let’s look at the mystery Paul speaks of later. I’ve interacted with many who deny that Israel was ever divorced or put away. Hosea is just one of a few prophets that describes this and just by the few verses we’ve looked at it’s hard to ignore. From chapters 4-14 it get’s pretty dark to be honest. We want to reflect on the grace seen in the early chapters, but we must acknowledge that without repentance (T’shuva=turning from our sin and repenting) we will not be one of the five virgins who had their oil. I suggest everyone read the whole book of Hosea and see that Israel is being taught a hard lesson but from that many nations will come to know Yahweh. Yahweh’s heart bleeds over what has been done to His relationship with Israel. Without obedience and faithfulness, we cannot say we love G-d. A bride must act according to her husband’s wishes and seek to know his desires just as Christians we need to seek the scriptures to know G-d’s desires for us. We cannot love G-d in our own way, this is the trap Israel fell into over and over.
At the end of chapter 14 He describes Ephraim (the Northern Kingdom) as a tree with great roots. Despite how we may fail Yahweh, His plan continues. He often uses our sin and mistakes for good, even though this doesn’t make our actions right. Israel was sown amongst the nations in order to bless them with the knowledge of G-d’s word. The history and miracles of Yahweh were given to a world that may not have ever heard of him otherwise. The victories of HaSatan may seem devastating at the time, but Yahweh will preserve His kingdom and grow it into a great tree with many branches grafted-in.
Let’s look at a few more verses from Hosea that indicate the marriage to be completed after the 2nd coming.
2:2 Plead with your mother, plead: for she is not my woman, neither am I her man.
5:14 For to Efrayim I will be like a lion, and like a young lion to the house of Y’hudah – I will tear them up and go away; I will carry them off, and no one will rescue.
15 I will go and return to my place, till they admit their guilt and search for me, seeking me eagerly in their distress.”
Yahweh’s dwelling or footstool is Israel, but this verse is about repentance more than a returning to the land even though both will eventually happen for those that repent and walk in obedience.
6:1 Come, let us return to ADONAI; for he has torn, and he will heal us; he has struck, and he will bind our wounds.
2 After two days, he will revive us; on the third day, he will raise us up; and we will live in his presence.
3 Let us know, let us strive to know ADONAI. That he will come is as certain as morning; he will come to us like the rain, like the spring rains that water the earth.
4 “Efrayim, what should I do to you? Y’hudah, what should I do to you? For your ‘faithful love’ is like a morning cloud, like dew that disappears quickly.
5 This is why I have cut them to pieces by the prophets, slaughtered them with the words from my mouth – the judgment on you shines out like light.
6 For what I desire is mercy, not sacrifices, knowledge of God more than burnt offerings.
7 “But they, just like men, have broken the covenant, they have been faithless in dealing with me.
Here we see some possible prophetic pictures of Yeshua’s first coming, death and resurrection. Hosea also shows us that Yahweh requires faith and obedience, we cannot just go through the motions or worship in our own way.
7:13 Woe to them! for they have strayed from me. Destruction to them! for they have wronged me. Am I supposed to redeem them, when they have spoken lies against me?
14 They have not cried out to me from their hearts, even though they wail on their beds.
Like a good father, Yahweh wants his children to acknowledge how they have wronged him and repent before the final redemption occurs.
8:13 They offer me sacrifices of flesh and eat them, but ADONAI does not accept them. Now he will recall their crimes and punish their sins – they will return to Egypt. 14 For Isra’el forgot his maker
9:3 They won’t remain in the land of Adonai; instead Efrayim will return to Egypt, and they will eat unclean food in Ashur.
9:17 My God will cast them aside, because they wouldn’t listen to him, and they will become wanderers among the Goyim.
The return to Egypt may have been literal for some but it is more likely Egypt is being used as an idiom for the world and 9:17 supports this: they will be scattered among the nations, taken away from the promise land like they were back in bondage in Egypt once more. In a way we are living in a divorced state, but I think Hosea actually captures that picture well when He takes Gomer back but does not sleep with her: we are still Yah’s people, but we are not receiving the full blessings of that marriage and it’s not because of Him but because of what we have done. ⚠️ Both Israel and Judah have been “divorced” from the land but not from their covenant with YHWH.
10:5 The inhabitants of Shomron are frightened of the calf-gods of Beit-Aven. Its people mourn over it; its priests tremble over it, over its glory, which has left it.
11:2 But the more [the prophets] called them, the farther they went from them. They sacrificed to the ba’alim and offered incense to idols.
3“Yet it was I who taught Efrayim to walk; I took them by their arms. But they did not know that it was I who was healing them,
4 who was guiding them on through human means with reins made of love.
We find it easy to mock the Israelites for the stiff-necked ways, but I think there’s benefit in saying that there was likely great deception happening then just as it happens in Christianity today. Although these idols had no power within themselves, it is theorized by some that these were golems—vessels that demons or angels would inhabit. When Yahweh chose a land and people, He willingly gave power to the other gods of the nations that surrounded. To say Yahweh had power over gods that didn’t exist is almost like saying Yahweh is stronger than the cookie monster or Darth Vader. It gives less credit to Yahweh if these elohim or divine council did not truly exist. *I suggest Dr. Michael Heiser’s Unseen Realm if you want more along that line of thinking.
We also see that the golden calf was worshiped by Israel as a form of Yahweh. They weren’t so dumb to just worship another elohim just after being delivered out of Egypt, it’s just how they chose to worship Yahweh. I believe Israel was deceived into worshiping idols with the same line of thinking as with the golden calf. They wanted to worship Yahweh in their own way or how the other nations engaged in worship. Yahweh made it clear at Mount Sinai and in Hosea that we are not worship Him as the pagans do. I’ve learned to ask myself this question recently in my walk: am I worshiping G-d how the bible tells me too, or is it by following my heart or doing it as those around me are?
10:12 If you sow righteousness for yourselves, you will reap according to grace. Break up unused ground for yourselves, because it is time to seek ADONAI, till he comes and rains down righteousness upon you.
We are called again to seek Yahweh. Have the oil in our lamps for when He returns to take us as His bride. Faith and obedience call us to turn from our ways and repent. Redemption gives the bride garments of white, but we have to choose to put them on and not return to the mire and dirty them once more. For Yeshua Ben David is coming back for a bride and not an adulteress.
The Torah portion I had studied before the sermon that night was B’Shalach (when He sent/ Let go). It is the crossing of the Red Sea and the entering of the wilderness. We’ve already seen that Egypt is often used as an idiom for the world many times in the bible. When God says do not return to Egypt, He is saying do not return to your worldly ways. Just as the Hebrews once lived in the world, had to pass through a medium of water (baptism, which is actually the definition of Hebrew—being born again) and enter into the Promise Land after enduring the trials of the wilderness (our Christian walk). This parallels what Hosea is describing a second bondage in Egypt, a second calling out and baptism and our walk in the wilderness before He brings us back into the Promise Land (His presence).
I mentioned the mystery of redeeming the bride above. Here is the dilemma.
“Then her former husband [Yahweh] who divorced her [Israel] must not take her [Israel] back to be his wife after she has been defiled; for that is an abomination before Yahweh.” (Deut 24:4a)
Paul recognizes this issue based on his background in Torah.
Or do you not know, brethren (for I speak to those who know the law), that the law has dominion over a man as long as he lives? (Rom 7:1)
He then explains how a woman is bound with a covenant to her husband only as long as he is alive; free to remarry after his death.
For the woman (Israel/Gomer) who has a husband is bound (in covenant) by the law to her husband as long as he lives. But if the husband dies, she is released from the law of her husband. (Rom 7:2)
Let’s view verse three with respect to what we’ve learned from Hosea.
So then if, while her husband (Yahweh) lives, she [Israel] marries another man (Ba’al/our masters), she will be called an adulteress; but if her husband dies, she is free from that law, so that she is no adulteress, though she has married another man. (Rom 7:3)
By now you probably have figured out where this is going. Yeshua paid the price in a very symbolic way.
Therefore, my brethren, you also have become dead to the law (law of sin and death not the Torah) through the body of Christ, that you may be married to another–to Him who was raised from the dead, that we should bear fruit to God. (Rom 7:4)
Having wiped out the handwriting of requirements (death because of sin/adultery) that was against us, which was contrary to us. And He has taken it out of the way, having nailed it to the cross. (Col 2:14)
If we read the end of the book without reading the front, including books like Hosea we may make the mistake that the law/Torah has been done away with even though Yeshua says Himself He did not come to abolish it but to fully preach and practice the Torah. Hosea gives a great context to understand how Yeshua redeemed His bride Israel. Paul probably had the book of Hosea memorized and once the scales were removed from his eyes, he was able to see this great mystery and explain it to all his brothers and sisters. Peter even warns that many take Paul out of context and fall into the error of lawlessness. Hope this made your wheels turn.
Shalom,
Nathanael Klein
Side notes:
Many theories revolve around the lost northern tribes and there is probably a scattered bit of truth in them all. They were dispersed and likely are in many ways still considered in the diaspora, living out their punishment until the time of the end. Some likely did return or in fact managed to escape being taken into captivity and we also know many did join Judah. The northern kingdom is mentioned by Josephus during Antiochus reign and, being a Levite, he does not speak highly of them. From reading the new testament, or Brit Chadashah, we see that Jews were not fond of those living in the land of Samaria. Ephraim (northern kingdom referred to this way by the prophets) gave herself over to interbreeding and had their own temple on Mount Gerizim. Josephus recounts that when faced with persecution, they would call themselves Arabs and even renamed their temple the temple of Jupiter Hellenius to appease Antiochus. In other times they called themselves Jews when it suited them. Samaritans survived to this day and now hold they keep the true faith of Moses and that Judaism is altered since the Babylonian captivity, a little truth in every lie here as well. They also hold the contention that Mount Gerizim is the true place of worship, established since the time of Joshua. I’m not here to make an argument either way, but renaming a temple dedicated to Yahweh for a pagan deity in the face of persecution does not bode well for such a lukewarm people. In stark contrast of this event we see the Judeans take a different approach with the advent of legalism created during the Hasmonean Dynasty.
Hosea 4:13 seems to speak of Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal.
They sacrifice on the mountaintops
and burn offerings on the
hills,
under oak, poplar and
terebinth,
where the shade is pleasant.
Therefore your daughters turn
to prostitution
and your daughters-in-law to
adultery.
We are only to sacrifice where Yahweh has appointed us to unless He specifically instructs you to such as with Noah or Elijah’s sacrifices.
5 But you shall seek the place that the LORD your God will choose out of all your tribes to put his name and make his habitation there. There you shall go, 6 and there you shall bring your burnt offerings and your sacrifices, your tithes and the contribution that you present, your vow offerings, your freewill offerings, and the firstborn of your herd and of your flock. (Deut. 12:5-7, ESV)
Josiah was a king who the scriptures say ‘turned to Yahweh with all His heart’ after discovering the Torah scroll in the temple.
19 And Josiah removed all the shrines also of the high places that were in the cities of Samaria, which kings of Israel had made, provoking the LORD to anger. He did to them according to all that he had done at Bethel. 20 And he sacrificed all the priests of the high places who were there, on the altars, and burned human bones on them. Then he returned to Jerusalem. (2 Kings Chapter 23:19-20, ESV)
Are the Israelites like the Ark of the Covenant taken by the philistines? When in pagan lands, the Ark caused chaos. In a similar way, the Jews were seen as vermin by many nations because of their success; one of Ark’s plagues actually being rats. The most known example of this is Hitler’s Germany. There is a documentary called the “Greatest Story Never Told” for free on Youtube. Although I don’t agree with everything in that very long video, it does show how Germany recovered from a very great economic depression once they had turned against the Jews. Hitler created more jobs than any leader to date. We see Hitler today as the villain, but in 1940 the majority of German people saw him as a hero just as many will one day see the Anti-Christ as the savior of the world. The point is, that Israel is Yahweh’s people and certain blessings and curses follow them no matter what land they dwell in. It is also interesting to note that the only book to describe what happened to the Ark of the Covenant was Baruch, who was the scribe of the prophet Jeramiah. Baruch describes the siege of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar II in 589BC and how Yahweh caused the walls to be toppled by angels and the Ark to be swallowed by the earth so that the Babylonians could not claim they conquered G-d’s city. The Ark was taken away just as Israel was taken away into captivity.